PNE Online
Welcome to PNE-Online. Why not register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox! You can also join up as a forum Patron to help support in the running costs of the forum.

Time to stop taking the knee?

No, its anti semitism. Islam isn't a race either. There's a reason there's a separate word for it. You can't rewrite definitions to fit your opinion.

A race is a category of humankind that shares certain distinctive physical features.
Youre wrong but I`ll leave you with this.

Racism is based on the idea that there are different human races: the 'white race', the 'black race', the 'yellow race', and the 'red race'. People of the same race are assumed to share certain characteristics.

Hitler and the National Socialists (Nazis) also believed that people could be divided into races. And they believed that the races were in competition with each other. According to the Nazis, the Jews were a weak, dangerous, and inferior race that did not belong in Germany.

The ideas of Hitler and the Nazis were racist. After the Second World War, science showed that the classification of humanity into different races is wrong. There is only one race: the human race.
Conclusion: Jews are not a race, and categorising people according to race is wrong and dangerous. Even so, some people still believe in the concept. If it is the basis for their hatred of Jews, it is undoubtedly racist.

We should also remember that the Semitic people are an ethnic and cultural group so are an actual race

 
Youre wrong but I`ll leave you with this.




We should also remember that the Semitic people are an ethnic and cultural group so are an actual race

If I'm wrong then so is the Oxford Dictionary.

You're misrepresenting religious bigotry as racism.

The conclusion you've just posted even states 'Jews are not a race.'
 
No, its anti semitism. Islam isn't a race either. There's a reason there's a separate word for it. You can't rewrite definitions to fit your opinion.

A race is a category of humankind that shares certain distinctive physical features.
A race is many things - and can class a social group, a nationality, a religion, and many other groups. It really does depend on how you define it and, as is the case in English more than most languages, that is not easy.

So, when I write a paper about racism, I have to spend quite a long time going through the various definitions before laying out which ones I am going to use for the paper.
 
Last edited:
If I'm wrong then so is the Oxford Dictionary.

You're misrepresenting religious bigotry as racism.

The conclusion you've just posted even states 'Jews are not a race.'
Dictionaries in English don't define how words should be used - they define how they are used.

That's one of the nuances of the English language and why defining any word is difficult and subject to debate.
 
Middlesbrough players didn’t take the knee.

Times are changing!
 
You mean this conclusion?

Yes. They've got it incorrect too. As Jews aren't a race, racism would be the wrong definition.

Dictionaries in English don't define how words should be used - they define how they are used.

That's one of the nuances of the English language and why defining any word is difficult and subject to debate.

Erm, I'd argue that most of our language has a universally accepted definition.
 
Yes. They've got it incorrect too. As Jews aren't a race, racism would be the wrong definition.



Erm, I'd argue that most of our language has a universally accepted definition.
Accepted, but with a lot of room for debate - as I said, English dictionaries reflect how a word is used and defined. In the case of racism, different dictionaries give lots of different definitions for it. Some in line with how you define it, some in line with how I define it - because both definitions are used.

Hence, as noted before, the need to set out in a paper exactly how you intend to use it before you start, to prevent confusion.

As it happens, the definition of racism according purely to physical characteristics is starting to fall out of usage. Partly due to academia, where it is rarely used like that due to some unsavoury links with the past, and partly because of social pressure. Society itself is shifting the definition over time.
 
Accepted, but with a lot of room for debate - as I said, English dictionaries reflect how a word is used and defined. In the case of racism, different dictionaries give lots of different definitions for it. Some in line with how you define it, some in line with how I define it - because both definitions are used.

Hence, as noted before, the need to set out in a paper exactly how you intend to use it before you start, to prevent confusion.

As it happens, the definition of racism according purely to physical characteristics is starting to fall out of usage. Partly due to academia, where it is rarely used like that due to some unsavoury links with the past, and partly because of social pressure. Society itself is shifting the definition over time.

Arguably the same is happening with gender.

I would say we're attempting to change accepted definitions to promote an agenda.
 
Arguably the same is happening with gender.

I would say we're attempting to change accepted definitions to promote an agenda.
A fair point, and it is certainly possible to push how a language is defined in a certain way.

But, because English is such a fluid language, it can also drift naturally and evolve. That's the main reason I love it!
 
I saw a cocktail on the menu in a restaurant today, a Negroni, am I allowed to say that when I order it or should I just point?
 
Is there a certain way to take the knee. Which knee do you kneel on, And which arm do you salute Black power
 
Is there a certain way to take the knee. Which knee do you kneel on, And which arm do you salute Black power
There's no correct arm. Tommy Smith and John Carlos had agreed to take a pair of gloves each to the medal ceremony, but one of them forgot so they ended up sharing a pair, and therefore raising different arms.

Screenshot 2020-12-09 at 10.32.40 PM.png
 
Top