What's new
PNE Online
Welcome to PNE-Online. Why not register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox! You can also join up as a forum Patron to help support in the running costs of the forum.

Killkenny sending off.

Benizz said:
According to SSN, if PNE appeal the sending off and proved it wasn't Kilkenny, Garner would then be automatically banned for 3 games.Should Kilkenny take one for the team??
Click to expand...

that will be down to grayson that i saw a punch thrown by garner maybe wrong
 
According to the FA rules we HAVE to appeal if we know it was the wrong man sent off.

Otherwise the club can also face a charge.
 
IanBogie9 said:
Grayson has just been on the radio saying the sending off should have been two yellows, one for the foul and one for the arguing, and that the culprit was probably Welsh, who is due to serve a suspension this weekend anyway, for bookings he picked up against Tranmere, when he was player of the month, and season, last week.
Click to expand...
Think Welsh has only been booked twice this season (Bradford and Notts County games)
 
keithaw said:
Another angle to think about is that if the FA decide to wipt out Kilkenny red card & decide Garner only deserves a yellow card for his action. Then Garner would be sent off for picking up 2 yellow cards & then only serves a 1match ban instead.
Click to expand...
Would be difficult for them to do that, as, had he had a yellow early in the game, he could argue that he would have been more cautious in his approach. If FA do take that approach though, it would be seen to have a fair effect
 
europne said:
I have no doubt that the FA and referees assoc are struggling this morning with how to deal with this without making more of a fuk up of it!

1. Was it a sending off?
2. Who was it?
3. Wrong man was dismissed.
4. What evidence is there to sort the mess?
5. Assessors report will no doubt show officials had a very bad evening.

That ref has caused some real issues with this !

Some decisions to be made there.

And quickly.
Click to expand...

The referee's report may also influence the outcome. If the 4th official has told him that he'd sent the wrong man off (which seemed to be the case) I assume that would have to be included in the refs report. In addition it's also mentioned on another thread that the Chris Robertson booking was also a case of mistaken identity. The actual culprit had already been booked and therefore should have also received his marching orders, unbelievable !
 
Best approach...... Shhhh, say nowt and hope it all goes away... you never know the FA might just do the same ! :)
 
Liberation said:
Best approach...... Shhhh, say nowt and hope it all goes away... you never know the FA might just do the same ! :)
Click to expand...

I think if PNE keep quite about the Red card & the FA found out that we deliberately kept quite about it they can give us a hefty fine under a misconduct charge.
 
keithaw said:
I think if PNE keep quite about the Red card & the FA found out that we deliberately kept quite about it they can give us a hefty fine under a misconduct charge.
Click to expand...

If this is the case, why does the totally incompetent ref who made terrible decisions all night, this included, get away scot free
 
Bloody sky aren't helping publicising it.

We are going to get penalised TWICE.

Losing Kilkenny last night (although we won but players expended much more energy) and then garner will most likely get banned for 3 games.
 
Sports Lawyer said:
Bloody sky aren't helping publicising it.

We are going to get penalised TWICE.

Losing Kilkenny last night (although we won but players expended much more energy) and then garner will most likely get banned for 3 games.
Click to expand...

How is that any sort of injustice? In fact there was probably a couple of advantages for us. If Garner had been correctly dismissed, then

  • there would be a fair argument that we would not have won the game.
  • the other 10 players would have had their energy depleted, just the same
  • Kilkenny would have been one of those players. At least he should be fresh for Saturday!
 
Regardless said:
How is that any sort of injustice? In fact there was probably a couple of advantages for us. If Garner had been correctly dismissed, then

  • there would be a fair argument that we would not have won the game.
  • the other 10 players would have had their energy depleted, just the same
  • Kilkenny would have been one of those players. At least he should be fresh for Saturday!
Click to expand...

But he isn't eligible to play Saturday.
 
Top